Ghai Law Firm
Call for a free consultation:
(770) 792-1000
  • ABOUT
    • Testimonials
    • Join Us
  • Practice Areas
    • Personal Injury
      • Pedestrian Accident
      • Car Accidents
        • Speeding Accident
        • Drinking and Driving Accidents
        • Left Hand Turn Accident
        • Rear-End Collision
        • Reckless Driving Accident
        • Uber Accidents
        • Hit-and-Run Accidents
        • Texting and Driving Accident
          • Texting and Driving Under 18
      • Truck Accident
        • Lane Usage Accident
        • Traumatic Brain Injury
      • Product Liability
        • Defective Drugs
        • Defective Medical Device
      • Premises Liability
        • Slip and Fall Accidents
      • Wrongful Death
      • Dog Bite
    • Bankruptcy
      • Debt Relief
      • Credit Card Debt
      • Chapter 13 Bankruptcy
      • Chapter 7 Bankruptcy
      • Foreclosure Bankruptcy
      • Free Legal Case Review
      • Medical Bills Bankruptcy
      • Rebuild Your Credit
      • Wage Garnishments
  • Areas We Serve
    • Kennesaw Personal Injury Lawyer
      • Kennesaw Bankruptcy Lawyer
    • Acworth Personal Injury Lawyer
      • Acworth Bankruptcy Lawyer
    • Marietta Personal Injury Lawyer
      • Marietta Bankruptcy Lawyer
    • Smyrna Personal Injury Lawyer
  • FAQs
  • Blog
  • Videos
  • Contact

Chapter 13 Debtors In North Carolina Are Not Entitled To Hardship Discharge

Home » Chapter 13 Debtors In North Carolina Are Not Entitled To Hardship Discharge

 

IN RE: MARY ANN MEEK and ALLEN JOSEPH MEEK, DEBTORS.

CASE NO. 10-02155-8-JRL

UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF NORTH CAROLINA RALEIGH DIVISION

Dated: April 10, 2012

 

 

SO ORDERED.

____________
J. Rich Leonard
United States Bankruptcy Judge

CHAPTER 13
ORDER

This matter came before the court on the debtors’ motion for hardship discharge. A hearing was held on April 4, 2012, in Raleigh, North Carolina.

On March 18, 2010, the debtors filed a petition for relief pursuant to chapter 13 of the Bankruptcy Code. The debtors chapter 13 plan was confirmed on February 24, 2011. Pursuant to the plan, the debtors are required to make a monthly payment of $2,358.00. At the time the debtors filed the present motion for hardship discharge, they had paid a total of $47,517.00 into the plan, which constitutes 48% of their total plan payments.

In August 2011, the male debtor, who was the sole provider for the debtors’ family, secured employment in Boulder, Colorado, and soon thereafter, the debtors and their children relocated accordingly. At the hearing, the female debtor testified that the male debtor accepted the position in Boulder because it provided better job security. The male debtor also benefitted

Page 2

For a free legal consultation, call (770) 792-1000

from an increase in annual salary from approximately $86,280.00 to $90,600.00. The debtors amended schedules I and J to reflect the change in income and the family’s expenses in Boulder. Without including the chapter 13 plan payment of $2,358.00, the debtors schedules reflect a combined monthly take-home income of $6,524.50 and monthly expenses totaling $7,104.00. Beyond the income listed, the debtors do not anticipate additional funds with which to support their chapter 13 plan. Based on these facts, the debtors contend that although they have not completed their chapter 13 plan payments, they are entitled to discharge pursuant to 11 U.S.C. § 1328(b), as the failure to complete the plan payments is due to circumstances representing just cause why they should not be held accountable.

Pursuant to § 1328(b), a hardship discharge is only available if—

(1) the debtor’s failure to complete such payments is due to circumstances for which the debtor should not justly be held accountable;
(2) the value, as of the effective date of the plan, of property actually distributed under the plan on account of each allowed unsecured claim is not less than the amount that would have been paid on such claim if the estate of the debtor had been liquidated under chapter 7 of this title on such date; and
(3) modification of the plan under section 1329 of this title is not practicable.

11 U.S.C. § 1328(b). Therefore, it is for the court to determine whether the debtors’ inability to continue making plan payments is due to circumstances “beyond the debtors’ control.” In re Tatum, No. 05-00809-8-JRL, at *3 (Bankr. E.D.N.C. Oct. 31, 2007) (citing In re Edwards, 207 B.R. 728, 731 (Bankr. N.D. Fla. 1997)). Generally, a hardship discharge will be granted under § 1328(b) “when a debtor has suffered from catastrophic circumstances that directly cause the debtor to be unable to complete plan payments.” Id. (quoting In re Bandilli, 231 B.R. 836, 840 (B.A.P. 1st Cir. 1999)).

Page 3

Click to contact our personal injury lawyers today

The court finds that the debtors are not experiencing circumstances that justify not holding them accountable for completion of their chapter 13 plan payments. The male debtor left his job in North Carolina to accept employment in Colorado, which offered better pay and job security. On their schedule J, the debtors have essentially substituted their mortgage payment in North Carolina with a rental payment in Colorado, but beyond that, their expenses and overall financial situation seem relatively unchanged. These are not the type of facts that justify a hardship discharge. See id. (granting hardship discharge where the “debtors’ failure to complete plan payments is due to the male debtors’ sudden inability to return to his job because of severe disabling injuries to his chest and shoulder”).

Based on the foregoing, the debtors’ motion for hardship discharge is DENIED.

Call or text (770) 792-1000 or complete a Free Case Evaluation form

Bankruptcy Blog Posts:

Bankruptcy Filings Continuing To Rise In 2010

Due to high unemployment and an uncertain economic climate, consumer bankruptcy filings in America have increased in 2010. According to statistics reported by the American Bankruptcy Institute, a

Chapter 7 Bankruptcy and Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Comparison

Good Morning, this is Roger Ghai of www.Chapter7attorneys.com. I wanted to do a little informational video on bankruptcy options. In particular, Chapter 7 bankruptcy options and Chapter 13 bankruptcy

Filing Chapter 7 Bankruptcy – January 2010 Talk Law Radio Show Transcript

Janice: Good afternoon Atlanta and welcome to News & Talk 1380 WAOK. This is Janice Mathis and we’re here this afternoon and every Sat. afternoon at 1pm to talk with one of our lawyers who’s

Difference Between Chapter 13 & Chapter 7 Bankruptcy – March 2010 Talk Law Radio Show Transcript

Janice: Good afternoon Atlanta and welcome to Legal Talk. This is Janice Mathis. This is my favorite hour of the weekend. I learn something new every weekend talking to these brilliant lawyers we have

Bankruptcy FAQ:

Bankruptcy FAQ
Bankruptcy FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions: Table of Contents Who is permitted to file and maintain a chapter 7 case? Who should not file a Chapter 7 case? Is there anything that a person must do

Can Creditors Be Sued For Trying To Collect Debt After You File For Bankruptcy
Can Creditors Be Sued For Trying To Collect Debt After You File For Bankruptcy

The injunction is formally issued pursuant to 11 U.S.C. 362(a), commonly referred to as the Automatic Stay provision of the bankruptcy code, and it prohibits creditors from making further attempts to

Can Your Home Be Sold In Bankruptcy If You Don’t File Bankruptcy But Your Spouse Files Bankruptcy?
Can Your Home Be Sold In Bankruptcy If You Don’t File Bankruptcy But Your Spouse Files Bankruptcy?

In a recent case, In re Beck Mrs. Beck filed for bankruptcy protection but her husband did not. Together they owned a property which was valued at about $530,000.00. The property had actually been in

Can You Claim A Homestead Exemption In A Home You Do Not Live In?
Can You Claim A Homestead Exemption In A Home You Do Not Live In?

The Chapter 7 trustee objected to Mrs. Goulakos’s claim of exemption because she did not live in the house and because she was not the one who claimed the homestead exemption under Massachusetts

Free Case Evaluation

Convenient and Confidential

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Bankruptcy FAQ

    Bankruptcy FAQ

    Can You Keep Your House If You File For Chapter 7 Bankruptcy?

    Can You Keep Your House If You File For Chapter 7 Bankruptcy?

    Can Creditors Be Sued For Trying To Collect Debt After You File For Bankruptcy

    Can Creditors Be Sued For Trying To Collect Debt After You File For Bankruptcy

    Let Ghai Law Fight For You.

    We’re here to provide help when you need us. Fill out this form below and I’ll reach out to discuss your case.

      Ghai Law Firm
      Call for a free consultation:
      (770) 792-1000

      Office Location

      LAW OFFICES OF ROGER GHAI

      1301 SHILOH RD NW STE 430

      KENNESAW GA   30144

      Mon-Fri: 9AM - 6PM

      Important Links

      • About
      • Practice Areas
      • Areas We Serve
      • Contact

      Practice Areas

      Personal Injury Lawyer Bankruptcy Attorney

      Ghai Law Firm

      Cobb County, Marietta, Kennesaw, Acworth

      "The Attorney"

      Site Map
      © Copyright 2023 Law Offices of Roger Ghai
      • ABOUT
        • Testimonials
        • Join Us
      • Practice Areas
        • Personal Injury
          • Pedestrian Accident
          • Car Accidents
            • Speeding Accident
            • Drinking and Driving Accidents
            • Left Hand Turn Accident
            • Rear-End Collision
            • Reckless Driving Accident
            • Uber Accidents
            • Hit-and-Run Accidents
            • Texting and Driving Accident
              • Texting and Driving Under 18
          • Truck Accident
            • Lane Usage Accident
            • Traumatic Brain Injury
          • Product Liability
            • Defective Drugs
            • Defective Medical Device
          • Premises Liability
            • Slip and Fall Accidents
          • Wrongful Death
          • Dog Bite
        • Bankruptcy
          • Debt Relief
          • Credit Card Debt
          • Chapter 13 Bankruptcy
          • Chapter 7 Bankruptcy
          • Foreclosure Bankruptcy
          • Free Legal Case Review
          • Medical Bills Bankruptcy
          • Rebuild Your Credit
          • Wage Garnishments
      • Areas We Serve
        • Kennesaw Personal Injury Lawyer
          • Kennesaw Bankruptcy Lawyer
        • Acworth Personal Injury Lawyer
          • Acworth Bankruptcy Lawyer
        • Marietta Personal Injury Lawyer
          • Marietta Bankruptcy Lawyer
        • Smyrna Personal Injury Lawyer
      • FAQs
      • Blog
      • Videos
      • Contact